top of page

What's Tough Love in Friendships? Standing by as a Friend Returns to a Toxic Relationship.


does tough love work

Supporting a Friend in a Toxic Relationship

True friends stick together through good times and bad times, sharing happy moments and helping each other when things get tough. One of the hardest things we might face is watching a friend go back to someone who treats them badly. It can make us feel worried, sad, and frustrated because we want to help but don't know how.


What's tough love? How does tough love sound in friendships?

Tough love means being honest with your friend because you care about them, even when the truth might be hard to hear. It's like when a parent makes their child do homework instead of watching TV - it might not be fun, but it's done with love. When helping a friend, tough love isn't about being mean or bossy. Instead, it's about gently helping them see when someone isn't treating them right while showing that you'll be there for them no matter what.


What does tough love sound like?

Here's an example of what you might say to a friend: "Sarah, I've noticed you've been hanging out with Jake again. I remember how sad you were when he was mean to you last time. I care about you a lot, and it worries me to see you getting hurt again. I'll support whatever choice you make, but I want you to know that you deserve someone who treats you with respect."


Understanding the Limits to Your Capacity to Give

When we try really hard to help our friends, we sometimes forget to take care of ourselves. It's like trying to pour water from an empty cup - you can't help others if you're completely drained. It's okay to take breaks and set limits on how much energy you can give to helping your friend.


The Psychological Dynamics of Returning to a Toxic Relationship

There are many reasons why someone might return to a relationship that isn't healthy:


  • They might feel comfortable with what's familiar, even if it's not good for them

  • They might be scared of being alone

  • They might think the person will change

  • They might have strong feelings for the person despite the bad treatment

  • Sometimes, they might be afraid of what the other person might do if they leave


What You Can Do


  • Listen without judging

  • Share your concerns calmly and kindly

  • Remind your friend of their good qualities

  • Help them connect with counselors or support groups

  • Keep checking in on them

  • Remember that they have to make their own choices

  • Be patient - it often takes time for someone to leave a bad relationship for good


It's not easy to stand at the crossroads of empathy and tough love. Watching a friend entangled in a toxic relationship, unable to extract themselves, is emotionally painful and tests our patience, compassion, and strength. Your concern and your presence matter. And while you may not have all the answers, your support, offered with love and understanding, is powerful.


If you are interested in learning about therapy or would like to setup an appointment with Person to Person Psychotherapy, serving New Jersey & New York residents, call 908-224-0007.

Comments


Join my mailing list and receive exclusive updates.

Thank you for signing up!

Existential therapist

908-224-0007
info@person2persontherapy.com

Long Valley, New Jersey

New York

AMANDA FRUDAKIS-RUCKEL
LICENSED CLINICAL SOCIAL WORKER 
New Jersey #44SC05919200
New York #095449

© Copyright 2025, Person to Person Psychotherapy and Counseling Services, LLC

bottom of page